JesusOnline.com

MENUMENU
  • Discover
    Evidence
    • About God
      • Has Science Discovered God?
      • Was Life Created by Design?
      • Accident or Intelligent Design?
      • Does God Exist?
      • “God Evidence” Videos
    • About Jesus
      • The Jesus of History: Man or Myth?
      • Was Jesus a Real Person?
      • Is Jesus God?
      • Was Jesus the Messiah?
      • Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?
      • More Questions…
      • “Jesus Evidence” Videos
    • About the Bible
      • Is the Bible True?
      • Are the Gospels Reliable?
      • The Gospel of Barnabas: Secret Bible?
      • Are the Gnostic Gospels Factual?
      • Is the Bible Infallible?
      • The Bible’s Buried Secrets
      • “Bible Evidence” Videos
  • MEET
    JESUS
    • Purpose for Life
    • Is Jesus Relevant Today?
    • God Loves You…
    • Can You be Forgiven?
    • Know God Personally
    • Is Jesus the Only Way to God?
    • Are You Going to Heaven?
    • Next Steps for New Believers
    • “Receive Jesus” Videos
  • Follow
    Jesus
    • Next Steps
      • Discover New Resources
      • Explore God’s Word
      • Connect with Believers
      • Why Grow?
      • “Next Steps” Videos
    • Living for Jesus
      • Born Again as a New Creation
      • Trusting by Faith
      • Abiding in Christ
      • Embracing Your New Identity
      • Loving God Wholeheartedly
      • Pursuing Truth in God’s Word
      • Depending on the Spirit’s Power
      • Obeying God Faithfully
      • Connecting with God’s Family
      • Resisting the Enemy
      • Advancing Christ’s Kingdom
      • “Living for Jesus” Videos
    • Time in God’s Word
      • Read eBible
      • Download the Bible
      • Devotionals
      • Key Verses
      • Bible Study Tools
      • “Time in God’s Word” Videos
    • Attitudes and Behavior
      • Pride vs. Humility
      • Fear vs. Faith
      • Overindulgence vs. Moderation
      • Immorality vs. Purity
      • Dissatisfaction vs. Contentment
      • Deceit vs. Honesty
      • Divisiveness vs. Harmony
      • Rebellion vs. Obedience
      • Irresponsibility vs. Diligence
    • Bible Study Courses
  • MORE
    • #GODisHOPE
    • FOREVER LOVED!
    • Students
    • Next Steps
    • Devotionals
    • Read eBible
    • Download the Bible
    • Bible Study Tools
    • Key Verses
    • Gospel Presentations
    • Answering Questions
    • “Share Jesus” Videos
    • Search
     Discover Evidence
  •   Overview
  •   Has Science Discovered God?
  •   Accident or Intelligent Design?
  •   Does God Exist?
  •   "God Evidence" Videos
  •   Overview
  •   Man or Myth?
  •   Was Jesus a Real Person?
  •   Is Jesus God?
  •   Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?
  •   "Jesus Evidence" Videos
  •   More Questions...
  •   Overview
  •   Is the Bible True?
  •   Are the Gospels Reliable?
  •   The Secret Gospel?
  •   Are Gnostic Gospels Factual?
  •   Is the Bible Infallible?
  •   The Bible's Buried Secrets
  •   "Biblical Evidence" Videos
  •   "Next Steps" Videos
  •   "Living for Jesus" Videos
  •   "Time in God's Word" Videos

We like you.
Like us back on social media!


The Jesus Family Tomb: Fact or Fiction?

Jesus’ Bones Discovered?

Has the tomb of Jesus Christ been discovered in the Jerusalem suburb of Talpiot?

In a 2007 Discovery Channel TV documentary, producer James Cameron (The Titanic) and Jewish director, Simcha Jacobovici, attempted to prove that Jesus’ burial cave and bones were discovered near Jerusalem. Cameron and Jacobovici further cited evidence that Jesus sired a son with Mary Magdalene.

If Jesus Christ’s tomb has really been discovered, then all of Christian history has been based upon a false claim—that Jesus physically rose from the dead, was seen alive by over 500 followers at once, spent 40 days teaching his disciples, and then ascended into heaven. But before we get caught up in another Da Vinci type conspiracy, let’s look at the facts behind Cameron’s claims.

The Facts Claimed:

1. In 1980 ten limestone bone boxes (ossuaries) dated to the first century, were discovered in an excavated tomb in the Jerusalem suburb of Talpiot.

2. Six inscriptions were discovered with names similar to or the same as some of Jesus Christ’s family and disciples:

  • Jesua, son of Joseph,
  • Mary
  • Mariamene e Mara
  • Mathew
  • Jofa
  • Judah, son of Jesua.

3. Cameron attempts to prove that Mariamene e Mara is Mary of Magdalene, and that she and Jesus had a son named “Judah son of Jesua”.

4. DNA analysis identifies that tissues from the ossuaries of Jesua and Mariamene e Mara were not related, raising the possibility they may have been married and had a child.

Checking The Evidence

So, what are the odds that this is Jesus’ tomb? According to Cameron and Jacobovici, the statistical improbability of these names belonging to another family than that of Jesus Christ is 600 to 1. However, scholars challenge many of the assumptions in their interpretation of the facts. Let’s look:

1. It is true that these ossuaries were discovered in an ancient tomb. But thousands of similar tombs have been discovered in Jerusalem. And ossuaries were often used for the bones of more than one individual. In fact, according to Dr. Craig Evans, PhD, author of Jesus and the Ossuaries, the tomb carried the bones of about 35 different individuals, and about half were from these ossuaries. Evans also notes that there was considerable contamination of the site.

2. Are Cameron and Jacobovici correct about the names they assert are on the ossuaries? Not according to many experts. Some were written in Aramaic, others in Hebrew, and another in Greek. This indicates they were not buried in a similar time period. It is not even clear that “Jesus” is named on any of the ossuaries. Dr. Evans’s personal examination of the ossuary was inconclusive. Stephen Pfann, a biblical scholar at the University of the Holy Land in Jerusalem, is also unsure that the name “Jesus” on the caskets was read correctly. He thinks it’s more likely the name “Hanun.” Ancient Semitic script is notoriously difficult to decipher.

Additionally, it should be noted that the names of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph were extremely common in the first century. About 25% of the women in Jesus’ day were named Mary. Joseph was also a common name. And about one in ten had the name, “Jesua”. Dr. Evans indicates that approximately 100 tombs have been discovered in Jerusalem with the name “Jesus” and 200 with the name “Joseph.” The name “Mary” is on far more.

“Each name with the exception of Mariamene seemed common to their period, and it was only in 1996 that the BBC made a film suggesting that, given the combination, it might be that family. The idea was eventually discounted, however, because, as New Testament scholar Richard Bauckham asserted ‘the names with Biblical resonance are so common that even when you run the probabilities on the group, the odds of it being the famous Jesus’ family are “very low.”

3. The statistical support for the entire “Jesus tomb” theory rises or falls on the question of Mary Magdalene. So did the name Mariamene e Mara mean Mary Magdalene, as Cameron and Jacobovici attempt to prove? Not according to most experts. Their interpretation is simply not supported by evidence. Bauckham notes, “The first use of ‘Mariamene’ for Magdalene dates to a scholar who was born in 185, suggesting that Magdalene wouldn’t have been called that at her death.”

So, even though Cameron and Jacobovici employed a statistician, Andrey Feuerverger, to support their case, his numbers were based upon assumptions disputed by the majority of scholars. In fact, Feuerverger himself admits that the assumptions were given to him by Jacobovici, and that the single biggest factor in his 600 to 1 odds was the identity of Mariamene e Mara being Mary of Magdalene. Feuerverger defends his role in an interview with Scientific American, “I did permit the number one in 600 to be used in the film—I’m prepared to stand behind that but on the understanding that these numbers were calculated based on assumptions that I was asked to use.”

Yet Dr. Randy Ingermanson’s statistical analysis of the probability indicates that there is less than one chance in 10,000 that this was the tomb of Jesus of Nazareth.

4. But what about the DNA tests? Doesn’t that prove Jesus was in the tomb? Let’s look closer at what the DNA test measured. It took residue (there were no bones to examine) from the ossuaries Jacobovici identified as belonging to both Jesua and Mariamene, and used mitochondrial DNA testing to see if they were related. The results proved to be negative, indicating to him that the two individuals were not related maternally. He thus assumes the two were married. But Bauckham isn’t impressed. He writes, “If ‘Jesus’ and ‘Mariamene’ weren’t related matrilineally, why jump to the conclusion that they were husband and wife, rather than being related through their fathers?”

It is the fact that these particular names have been discovered in the same tomb that has fueled speculation that it really could be Jesus’ tomb. But many scholars believe Cameron and Jacobovici have skewed the evidence to build a case that just isn’t there. Additionally, there are many contradictory questions that need to be answered before one jumps to a conclusion that overturns centuries of historical scholarship.

Continue reading page 2 of 3 about “The Jesus Family Tomb”

Pages: 1 2 3
| Next

Featured Videos

Is Jesus God?

Is Jesus God?

Dr Bobby Conway answers the question 'Is Jesus God?' [watch video]
Resurrection Factor

Resurrection Factor

Josh McDowell proves that the bible is historically accurate and reliable and the resurrection of Christ is a historical fact. [watch video]
How is Jesus Different?

How is Jesus Different?

Jesus defines Christianity, but what sets him apart from other leaders? [watch video]
Evidence Jesus Was God by Lee Strobel

Evidence Jesus Was God by Lee Strobel

The ancient world agrees that the tomb of Christ was empty. The resurrected Christ was seen by 515 eye witnesses. [watch video]
How Can We Know If Jesus Is God?

How Can We Know If Jesus Is God?

John Burke discusses evidence from the Bible and history that indicate Jesus is God. [watch video]

 

Jesus Evidence videos

Copyright ©    |   Jesus Online Ministries   |   Sitemap   |   Privacy Policy   |   Website Terms of Use Policy

TAKE JESUSONLINE WITH YOU

  GET THE FREE APP NOW